NORTHEAST FOOTBALL CONFERENCE
2019 Offensive Player of the Year: Dominique Shoffner, Monroe
2019 Defensive Player of the Year: Ji'Ayir Brown, Lackawanna
2019 Coach of the Year: Mark Duda, Lackawanna
| 2019 All-Northeast Football Conference Teams | ||||||||
| 1st Team Offense | 2nd Team Offense | QB | Dominique Shoffner | Monroe | QB | Nasir Boykin | ASA | Matt Cavallaro | Lackawanna | RB | Stephon Rucker-Carroll | ASA | RB | Calvin Bell | Lackawanna | Tyquan Brown | ASA | Clayton Scott Jr. | Monroe | WR | Norval Black | Lackawanna | WR | Richard Halim Dixon-King | Monroe |
| Jevin Frett | Monroe | Quentin Sanders | Lackawanna | Lucas Nunez | Monroe | Kaedin Robison | ASA | TE | Abdou Diop | ASA | TE | Sameer Parks | Lackawanna | OL | Egan Atkins | ASA | OL | Patrick Bien-Aime | Monroe | Tre Dorsey | Lackawanna | Stephon Jones | ASA | Scott Houseman | Lackawanna | Reggie Marks | Lackawanna | Cedrice Paillant | Monroe | Antwan Reed | ASA | Tairiq Stewart | ASA |
| 1st Team Defense | 2nd Team Defense | DT | Lorenzo Hernandez | ASA | DT | Daryl Davis | ASA | Devin Love | Monroe | Pheldarius Payne | Lackawanna | James Sackie | Lackawanna | Nadir Pineda | Monroe | DE | Durrell Johnson% | ASA | DE | Jahron Gayle | Monroe | Greg Rose | Lackawanna | Brandon Hickerson-Rooks | Lackawanna | LB | Timothy Donnahue | Monroe | LB | Rovny DaSilva | ASA | Malich Jacobs | ASA | Tyler Long | Lackawanna | KeShaun Moore | Lackawanna | Zharell Walker | Monroe | DB | Charles Amankwaa | Monroe | DB | Jeremiah Bryant | Monroe |
| Emmanuel Appiah-Takyi | Monroe | Khyon Fitzpatrick | ASA | |||||
| Ji'Ayir Brown@ | Lackawanna | Gianni Gamble | Lackawanna | Travell Cook | ASA | DeJahn Warren | Lackawanna | |
| 1st Team Special Teams | 2nd Team Special Teams | K | Cameron Ceccotti | Lackawanna | K | Andres Espinoza | ASA | Idrissa Nikiema | Monroe | P | Luke Payne# | Lackawanna | P | RS | Delvin Palmer | Lackawanna | RS |
@-2018 first-team selection; %-2018 second-team selection; #-only player nominated in position, promoted to first team