NORTHEAST FOOTBALL CONFERENCE
2016 Offensive Player of the Year: David Pindell, Lackawanna
2016 Defensive Player of the Year: Rashad Brandon, ASA
2016 Coach of the Year: Mark Duda, Lackawanna
| 2016 All-Northeast Football Conference Teams | ||||||||
| 1st Team Offense | 2nd Team Offense | QB | David Pindell | Lackawanna | QB | Ryan Barabe | ASA | Aaron Williams | Monroe | RB | Ryan Fulse | Monroe | RB | Troy Robinson | ASA | Marcelias Sutton | Lackawanna | Zahneer Shuler | Lackawanna | WR | Jerod Diggs | Lackawanna | WR | Mallory Claybourne | Lackawanna |
| Rakeem Lankston | Monroe | Brian Ingram | ASA | Javin Tandy! | ASA | Aaron Lewis | Monroe | Raekwon Purdy | Lackawanna | OL | Quadrick Barnes@ | Lackawanna | OL | Raymond Chase! | Monroe | Eric Carter | Monroe | Devon Davis | Lackawanna | Isaiah Hardy | Lackawanna | Macquel Hardy | ASA | Anthony Mayes | Lackawanna |
| 1st Team Defense | 2nd Team Defense | |||||||
| DT | Rashad Brandon# | ASA | DT | Gerron Pendarvis | Monroe | Nick Flores | Lackawanna | Kamari Jones-Hunter@ | Monroe |
| DE | Jalen Booker | Lackawanna | DE | Tim Soave | Lackawanna | Najee McKenzie | ASA | LB | Michael Kwegyir-Attah | Monroe | LB | Alonzo Guillaume | Monroe | Michael McGinnis | ASA | Levi Schockley | Monroe | Mustafa Mitchell | Lackawanna | Anthony Stubbs | Monroe | Shane Schuback | Lackawanna | Brad Zaffram | Lackawanna | DB | Lawrence Harrison | Monroe | DB | Jave Brown | Lackawanna | Joe Johnson | ASA | James Chukwurah | Lackawanna |
| Jatece Wright | Monroe | Darrius Stokes | Monroe | Tyrone Washington | Lackawanna | |||
| 1st Team Special Teams | 2nd Team Special Teams | K | Jared Calhoun | Monroe | RS | Wyl Miller | ASA | |
Honorable Mention: Monroe--Terrance Barfield, DE; Kadeen Dryden, DE; Richard Jernigan, LB.
!-2015 first team selection; @-2015 second team selection; #-2015 third team selection.